"You're the first." Jane is really, REALLY, not okay with that either. And she can't express that without hurting Pasha's feelings and that would probably kill what little soul Jane has left. She doesn't mean she doesn't want to hang out with her, or see her, or God just enjoy a non-lethal situation with her, but she doesn't want ANY OF THEM ON THIS STUPID ISLAND.

This was not a safe situation.

This was the exact opposite of a safe situation.